AI Prediction Market ResearchAi预测市场调研
I wrote the following as a "research report". You can use it directly as a material, and it will also facilitate the connection with the IFC / ISO / ICR system later.
Prediction Market Research Report (2025 Short Version)
1. Brief description of concepts and mechanisms
1. What is a prediction market?
Prediction Markets, also called Event Contracts, are essentially:
Allow participants to "bet" on the outcomes of future events (elections, policies, economic data, sports scores, technological milestones, etc.),
The price is the collective judgment of the group on the probability of the event occurring.
Typical form:
- "A certain candidate will be elected president in 2028?" - "Yes/No" contract, price 0–1 (or 0–100);
- “Will AI pass a certain benchmark test by 2026?”
- “Does a company’s revenue exceed $X billion in 2025Q4?”
The contract price approaches the subjective probability: for example, the price is at 0.73, which means the market believes that the probability of the event happening is about 73%.
2. Basic transaction structure
- The user buys the "YES/NO" contract;
- If the event occurs at expiration, the "YES" contract will be redeemed for 1 US dollar, and the "NO" contract will be reset to zero, and vice versa;
- You can sell it at any time like a stock;
- The platform makes money through spreads, handling fees or other value-added services.
3. Comparison with traditional forecasting methods
- Compared with expert predictions/research questionnaires, the prediction market has three advantages: 1) Participants have to express their opinions with "real money or limited chips" and there is less noise; 2) Prices are dynamic and continuously updated, which can reflect new information in real time; 3) Correction through the arbitrage mechanism: when the price deviates from the true probability, it will attract more rational participants to trade in the opposite direction.
2. Academic research conclusion: Is prediction market “really useful”?
1. Overall conclusion on accuracy
- Wolfers & Zitzewitz's data analysis of multiple electoral, macroeconomic and other scenarios shows that probabilistic forecasts of market output often outperform traditional methods such as polls and simple averages.
- The systematic review and Meta-Analysis found that: On average, prediction markets are approximately 79% more accurate overall than other alternative prediction methods (experts, questionnaires, simple models, etc.).
2. Typical experiment: IARPA prediction competition
- The U.S. Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Agency (IARPA) has organized prediction competitions spanning many years and thousands of problems: multiple research teams participated, using prediction markets, superforecasters, combination methods, etc. to compete;
- The results show that a carefully designed combination of prediction markets and top forecasters can significantly outperform traditional intelligence analysis and polling in long-term predictions.
3. “Internal Prediction Market”: Enterprise Scenario
- Internal enterprise prediction markets (such as Google, HP and other companies have done) are mainly used for: product launch time
- Sales target completion
- Project risk assessment
3. Current industrial structure and mainstream platforms
It can be roughly divided into three categories: regulated legal currency prediction markets, cryptocurrency prediction markets, and virtual currency/reputation prediction games.
1. Regulated fiat currency prediction market: Kalshi system
- Kalshi: Founded in 2018, headquartered in New York, USA;
- It has been authorized by the US CFTC to become a Designated Contract Market (DCM) and is currently one of the most important "compliance event contract exchanges".
- Contract coverage: inflation rate, interest rate, unemployment rate, election results, government shutdown, sports event indicators, etc.
Features:
- It has strong compliance and is suitable as a model for "financial derivatives + information market";
- The regulatory game is fierce and has a huge impact on product design and expansion pace.
2. Crypto prediction market: Polymarket, etc.
- Polymarket: A decentralized prediction market platform denominated in stablecoins such as USDC;
- Transaction volume hit a peak during the 2024 U.S. election, and there will be a second explosion in 2025 through token incentives.
Features:
- Growing extremely fast, event coverage is almost borderless (politics, sports, entertainment, encryption, technology...);
- Subject to regulatory restrictions in the United States (such as the previous settlement with the CFTC), it is mainly targeted at non-U.S. users or in gray areas;
- Token incentives make it more like a hybrid of “DeFi + Social + Speculation”.
3. Virtual currency/reputation-based prediction market: Manifold et al.
- Manifold Markets / Manifold: Use virtual currency Mana for trading, which is essentially a “toy money + reputation points” type prediction platform;
- Users can create a market on any topic, and the platform provides liquidity through the automatic market maker algorithm (CFMM/Maniswap);
- Emphasis on “predictive games + social”, not strictly financial products;
- The measured calibration data shows that even with "virtual currency + non-monetary income", the prediction accuracy still has reference value.
Other forms:
- Metaculus: a scientific research and technology prediction community;
- Open source project PlayMoney: a community-built prediction market framework.
4. Regulatory and legal environment
1. United States
- Federal level: The CFTC is responsible for regulating whether "event contracts" are legal derivatives;
- Kalshi, as a DCM, is under strict supervision.
Core controversy:
- Is the prediction market an “information market/hedging tool” or a “disguised gambling”?
- The regulatory boundaries have not yet been fully clarified, and the game will continue in the coming years.
2. EU, UK, etc.
- The overall strategy is cautious, incorporating more prediction markets into the financial derivatives/gambling regulatory framework, and strictly limiting large-scale promotion to retail investors;
- At the same time, it is relatively relaxed in scientific research, policy consultation, and internal prediction experiments.
3. China and East Asia
- China's supervision of "online gambling/lottery/feudal superstition" is very strict, and a monetary prediction market directly facing the public is basically unfeasible;
- But as: internal enterprise tools (e.g. project risk forecasting),
- Teaching/scientific research tools (virtual currency/statistics only, no redemption),
- There is still room for gamified Q&A (no money or winning or losing involved), but it just needs to be very careful about compliance and narrative.
5. Typical application scenarios
- Politics and Macroeconomics: Election results, policy implementation, inflation rate, interest rates, unemployment rate, etc. - are currently one of the most active trading directions.
- Sports: Championship ownership, game scores, player data, etc.;
- However, it highly overlaps with traditional sports betting and is one of the most controversial areas of current regulation.
- Technology and scientific research: Predict the results of a certain scientific research project, paper publication, technological breakthrough time, etc.;
- For example, the prediction market is used to predict the scientific research evaluation results (REF) of British universities, and the effect is better than traditional expert scoring.
- Enterprise management and product decision-making: Use the internal prediction market to replace "head-beating": new product launch time, sales target, project delay probability, etc.
- Community governance and public decision-making: DAO, open source communities, etc. can use prediction markets to estimate proposal approval rates, changes in community activity, token price ranges, etc.
6. Opportunity and risk assessment (an inspiration for you)
1. Opportunity points
- As a "collective intelligence aggregation layer": combined with large models/Agents to form an "AI + human predictor" collaborative system;
- Form a more sensitive "emotion & expectation radar" in terms of macro, technology trends, policy changes, asset pricing, etc.
2. Risk points
- Compliance: Any product involving the winning or losing of real money may be regarded as "gambling/gambling", with high compliance costs and great regulatory uncertainty;
7. Summary
- From the perspective of academic research: the prediction market is indeed a high-quality collective prediction mechanism in most scenarios, and is overall better than experts and polls;
- From the perspective of industry data: The transaction volume and number of users of platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket will increase rapidly in 2025, and a multi-billion-dollar "information derivatives market" has been formed;
下面这份我按“研究报告”来写,你可以直接当材料用,也方便后面和 IFC / ISO / ICR 体系对接。
预测市场研究报告(2025 简版)
一、概念与机制简述
1. 什么是预测市场?
预测市场(Prediction Markets),也叫事件合约(Event Contracts),本质是:
让参与者用“下注”的方式,对未来事件(选举、政策、经济数据、体育比分、科技里程碑等)的结果进行交易,
价格即为群体对该事件发生概率的集体判断。
典型形式:
- 「2028 年某候选人当选总统?」——“是 / 否”合约,价格 0–1(或 0–100);
- 「2026 年前 AI 是否通过某项基准测试?」
- 「某公司在 2025Q4 营收是否超过 X 亿美元?」
合约价格趋近 主观概率:例如价格在 0.73,即市场认为事件发生概率约 73%。
2. 基本交易结构
- 用户买入“YES / NO”合约;
- 到期时若事件发生,“YES”合约兑付 1 美元,“NO”归零,反之亦然;
- 中途可以像股票一样随时卖出;
- 平台通过点差、手续费或其他增值服务盈利。
3. 与传统预测手段对比
- 相比专家预测 / 调研问卷,预测市场有三个优势: 1)参与者要用“真金白银或有限筹码”表达观点,噪音较少; 2)价格动态、连续更新,可实时反映新信息; 3)通过套利机制纠偏:价格偏离真实概率时,会吸引更理性的参与者反向交易。
二、学术研究结论:预测市场是不是“真有用”?
1. 准确性总体结论
- Wolfers & Zitzewitz 对多个选举、宏观经济等场景的数据分析显示:预测市场产出的概率预测 通常优于民调和简单平均等传统方法。
- 系统综述和 Meta-Analysis 发现: 平均来看,预测市场 比其它替代预测方法(专家、问卷、简单模型等)整体准确度高约 79%。
2. 典型实验:IARPA 预测竞赛
- 美国情报高级研究计划署(IARPA)组织过跨多年、成千上万问题的预测竞赛: 多个研究团队参与,用预测市场、超级预测者(superforecasters)、组合方法等比拼;
- 结果表明,精心设计的预测市场与顶级预测者组合,在长期预测上可以显著优于传统情报分析与民调。
3. “内部预测市场”:企业场景
- 企业内部预测市场(如 Google、HP 等公司曾做过)主要用于: 产品上线时间
- 销售目标完成度
- 项目风险评估
三、当前产业格局与主流平台
大致可以分为三类:受监管的法币预测市场、加密货币预测市场、虚拟币 / 声誉型预测游戏。
1. 受监管的法币预测市场:Kalshi 系
- Kalshi: 2018 年成立,总部美国纽约;
- 已获得美国 CFTC 授权,成为 Designated Contract Market(DCM),是目前最重要的“合规事件合约交易所”之一。
- 合约覆盖:通胀率、利率、失业率、选举结果、政府关门、体育赛事指标等。
特点:
- 合规性强,适合作为“金融衍生品 + 信息市场”的样板;
- 监管博弈激烈,对产品设计和扩张节奏影响巨大。
2. 加密预测市场:Polymarket 等
- Polymarket: 以 USDC 等稳定币计价的去中心化预测市场平台;
- 在 2024 年美国大选期间交易量曾创高峰,2025 年通过代币激励等又迎来二次爆发。
特点:
- 增长极快,事件覆盖几乎无边界(政治、体育、娱乐、加密、科技…);
- 受美国等监管限制(例如此前与 CFTC 的和解),主要面向非美用户或灰色区域;
- 代币激励使其更像“DeFi + 社交 + 投机”的混合体。
3. 虚拟币 / 声誉型预测市场:Manifold 等
- Manifold Markets / Manifold: 使用虚拟货币 Mana 进行交易,本质是 “玩具钱 + 声誉积分”型预测平台;
- 用户可以创建任何话题的市场,平台通过自动做市商算法(CFMM/Maniswap)提供流动性;
- 强调“预测游戏 + 社交”,并非严格金融产品;
- 实测校准数据表明,即便是“虚拟币+非金钱收益”,预测精度依然有参考价值。
其他形态:
- Metaculus:偏科研、技术预测社区;
- 开源项目 PlayMoney:社区自建预测市场框架。
四、监管与法律环境
1. 美国
- 联邦层面: CFTC 负责监管“事件合约”是否属于合法衍生品;
- Kalshi 作为 DCM,受严格监管。
核心争议:
- 预测市场是“信息市场 / 对冲工具”, 还是“变相赌博”?
- 监管边界尚未完全厘清,未来几年仍会持续博弈。
2. 欧盟、英国等
- 总体策略偏谨慎,更多将预测市场纳入 金融衍生品 / 博彩 监管框架,严格限制面向散户的大规模推广;
- 同时,在科研、政策咨询、内部预测实验上相对宽松。
3. 中国及东亚
- 中国对“网络赌博 / 彩票 / 封建迷信”监管很严,直接面向公众的货币型预测市场基本不可行;
- 但作为: 企业内部工具(例如项目风险预测)、
- 教学/科研工具(虚拟币 / 仅统计,不兑付)、
- 游戏化问答(不涉金钱与输赢) 仍有空间,只是需要非常注意合规与叙事方式。
五、典型应用场景
- 政治与宏观经济: 选举结果、政策落地、通胀率、利率、失业率等——是目前交易最活跃的方向之一。
- 体育: 冠军归属、比赛比分、球员数据等;
- 但与传统体育博彩高度重叠,是当前监管争议最大的领域之一。
- 科技与科研: 预测某一科研项目成果、论文发表、技术突破时间等;
- 如用预测市场预估英国高校科研评估结果(REF)等,效果优于传统专家打分。
- 企业管理与产品决策: 用内部预测市场替代“拍脑袋”:新品上市时间、销量目标、项目延期概率等。
- 社区治理与公共决策: DAO、开源社区等可以用预测市场来预估提案通过率、社区活跃度变化、token 价格区间等。
六、机会与风险评估(给你的启发位)
1. 机会点
- 作为 “集体智能聚合层”: 与大模型 / Agent 结合,形成「AI + 人类预测者」协作系统;
- 在宏观、科技趋势、政策变动、资产定价等方面形成更敏锐的“情绪 & 预期雷达”。
2. 风险点
- 合规: 任何涉及真金白银输赢的产品,都可能被视作“博彩 / 赌博”,合规成本高、监管不确定性大;
七、小结
- 从学术研究看:预测市场在多数场景下,确实是一种高质量的集体预测机制,整体优于专家与民调;
- 从产业数据看: Kalshi、Polymarket 等平台 2025 年交易量与用户数都在快速上升,已经形成数十亿美元级别的“信息衍生品市场”;